Sunday, October 14, 2012

Low tech post edition

I am at a conference on Monday, so I am operating from an iPad pretending to be my laptop. I may be able to add pictures soon enough, but here is the meat of my post!

Here are some things to think about as you read Watchmen:
1. Check out the distorted time sequence of Dr. Manhattan's story (and how stories weren't told like this in the mid-1980s). See the start of this on page 17 and ending on page 28. Gibbons flashes from close-ups to panoramas, how scenes blur together, crossing one another, and finally telling a story of how Dr. M finds himself sulking on Mars. 
If you check out page 74 in Understanding Comics, you'll see that this way of telling a story doesn't really fit into any of McCloud's possibilities. It seems, at best, like a combination of #4 and #5, but out of sequence. I couldn't really call it non-sequitur. Watchmen was breaking many molds in terms of telling stories that cross many formats--art, literature, music, etc. 
Also, take a look at that quote by Albert Einstein on page 28. Einstein was also the son of a watchmaker. Yet, he too realized that atom power changes everything but our thinking. Superheroes change everything but our thinking. The solution lies in the heart of mankind, and we see the characters with heart not having much power and those who have power not having much heart.  
2. Let's take a look at some of the visuals in Watchmen as well as some expert transitions. Start at the bottom of page 12. We see our Black Freighter man looking at himself for the first time in a long time. he is not who he thinks he is anymore. Shift to Adrian Veidt. (On purpose! You look like Charles Manson, Alan Moore, but you can tell a damned good story!) He is not quite looking at his brown-haired assistant. She represents the sort of mindless babble we may have learned to turn our noses from. Veidt says that death "wasn't morbid to the ancient Egyptians. They saw it as launching on a spiritual discovery." Then, he metes out death himself, starting with a superhero-like move (blocks the bullet!) and then beating the crap out of the man with the gun. How do we he killed him? This plot twist is shown in the man's expression on page 16, to the far right. This does not look like a man ready to bite down on his poison capsule. It looks like a man who is getting a poison capsule crushed in his mouth, a man on the verge of a "spiritual discovery""?  Text alone does not convey this, and expression is a clear way to see how little Veidt is who he seems from the outside.  
3. Now, take a look at page 9. Here's another place where we see the text within the text telling us a lot about the characters in the "real" text. On the bottom of that page, Mr. Freighter grabs a bird from the sky and bites into its raw meat. Turn the page. We see Dreiberg eating a bird. He is Owl Man, who only has potency when he is wearing his suit, acting as a superhero. He does not really live well as a man. As Laurie is kicked out, she is dismissed with "chew on that."  So, Dan, what will you take and chew on? Are you up for this? This is Gibbons as well, creating the transitions that tie these characters and their messed up destinies together. This is subtle and multi-layered, something folks hadn't really been expecting from a comic before.

Monday, October 1, 2012

The Ending?



The End?

Here are a few ideas to think about:

1. Total Party Kill (TPK)--http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Total_Party_Kill
2. Matter v. Antimatter--http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3a1c_1TIGGw
3. Symbolically--Hana and Asterios are moving on; the dualism is over

Wednesday, September 26, 2012

No One Way of Looking at Asterios Polyp


Sorry about the title, but I just had to!



















If I had to pick one picture that would summarize Asterios Polyp, it would be this one. This comic is about duality, contrast. On the left is Hana, drawn in a sketchy style and with vibrant magenta. She is angry and her body shows it, with arms crossed and brow furrowed. Asterios is on the right, drawn as if he were a series of hard shapes. His head is symmetrical. You could divide his cyan-colored head down the middle. Where he stands there are only external lines, sharply delineating one shape from another. His posture is rigid and uncommunicative.

This comic is an exploration of what happens when the sharp and angular meet the gray and fuzzy. What happens to Asterios's when his worldview is so split? What happens when a binary view of the world encounters complexity?

The narrative is ostensibly written by Asterios's dead twin, Ignazio. Everything in this novel has a twin or is in a binary relationship: living/dead, woman/man, Hana/Asterios, magenta/cyan, present/past.
Even when Hana and Asterios blend (creating purple in their scenes of relative peace), the sameness/difference of the two is still explored. The angular head of Asterios looks like another version of Hana's head in the image above. She regards the dead deer with what looks like horror (wide-open eyes, frowning mouth), and Asterios regards the crashed vehicle coolly. Hana is looking at the end of life and Asterios looks at the end of structure. They see two different scenes in this one event: a car is wrecked as it hits a deer.

In a self-aware way, Mazzucchelli has Asterios study binary relationships in academia. The comic is about the binary life of a guy who studies binaries:


  The architectural (and literary and visual) school of thought that Polyp comes from is modernism: Modernism video.

The belief was that the world could be cleaned up and made better through streamlining and simplification. Though the roots of modernism are deep in history, it gained a lot of cultural weight after the first world war, as a startled world responded to the messy destruction of war on such a large scale, begun in such a tangled way.

One last note about the color: Cyan, yellow, and magenta are the basic colors of printing. Together, they create a full spectrum of colors: Animation of CMY color

Mazzucchelli is even examining what happens when we break the very lines down into their constituent colors. What makes up a full color world?

Here's what I'd like us to talk about on Monday:

  • The use of color; what does each color "mean"?
  • The use of white space, between panels
  • The ending--what's going on? Is it real? A metaphor? Does it matter?




Friday, September 7, 2012

Blog Reboot!






  The Blog Lives Again!

English 251 lives again at North Central Michigan College! I am really excited to continue the conversation about comics, and I invite any past students to hang out and follow. Some of the posts may be very course-related, so consider that if you choose to still follow the posts.